College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

UPDATE | UMass student pleads innocent to stabbing Amherst student

By Matt Rocheleau, Collegian Staff

Print this article

Published: Monday, February 9, 2009

Updated: Friday, February 13, 2009

Marcus Smith

Courtesy Amherst Police Department

UMass sociology major Marcus Smith, 21, has plead innocent to assault and battery charges with a deadly weapon (knife) in the alleged stabbing of an Amherst College Student.

A University of Massachusetts student pleaded innocent to a charge of assault and battery with a dangerous weapon (a knife) after being accused of stabbing an Amherst College student at an Amherst College dormitory Sunday morning.

Marcus Smith, 21, of 5 Codman Park, Apt. 3, Roxbury, Mass., a sociology major at UMass, was arraigned in Eastern Hampshire District Court in Belchertown on Monday and will be held without bail until his pre-trial hearing on March 12.

According to a probable cause statement by Amherst police Sgt. Brian Johnson, the victim, 20-year-old Issac Cameron “received six to seven stab wounds to his abdomen, back and neck areas.”

Police initially responded to a report of a double stabbing at Crossett Dormitory on Sunday at around 1:10 a.m. and found Smith, also injured, in the building’s basement bathroom.

 “Smith stated that he had been involved in a fight with an unknown male and as a result of this fight had been stabbed in the hand,” said Johnson’s report. “Smith then showed me a wound to the back of his left thumb, which was a deep, clean laceration approximately three-fourth inches in length.”

The report said Smith was wearing a purple T-shirt and a white undershirt which were “heavily stained with blood in several places,” though police observed no additional wounds than the one on Smith’s hand.

 “I asked Smith if he knew who had stabbed him, and he stated he did not,” wrote Johnson. “I asked him for a description of his assailant, and Smith stated he could not provide one, and that he never saw a knife.”

According to Johnson, when searched by police, no weapons were found on Smith’s person.

 “Smith stated that he became involved in an argument with an unknown individual over a girl he was dancing with,” the report said. “Smith stated he was punched in the nose by this person.”

One witness, 18-year-old Cory Atkins, a freshman at Amherst College, was interviewed at the scene.

 “Atkins stated that he witnessed a dark-skinned male wearing a purple and black shirt with a purple or black baseball hat involved in a physical altercation with his friend, Cameron,” said Johnson’s report. “Atkins did not see a knife used…[he] positively identified Smith as the individual he had witnessed fighting with Cameron.”

Cameron was transported by the Amherst Fire Department to Baystate Medical Center in Springfield, Mass., where he was in fair condition, said police.

Smith was brought to Cooley Dickinson Hospital in Northampton where he was treated for his hand injury and released into police custody afterwards, officials said.

Prior to his arraignment, Smith was held at the Hampshire County House of Correction in lieu of $25,000 cash bail.

Johnson’s report said the bail was $50,000.

Court documents provided a statement on why Smith is now being held without bail.

 “Given the serious nature of the offense and the injuries sustained during this knife attack, no condition of bail would assure the safety of the victim or the community,” said the document.

The maximum penalty for Smith’s charge is 10 years in prison.

Matt Rocheleau can be reached at mrochele@dailycollegian.com.

Comments

56 comments
Your name
Thu Aug 20 2009 10:02
I was at the party.
b2011
Wed May 20 2009 01:05
Good people can do terrible things. Marcus may have been a good brother, a good friend, a good student, but that does not mean he is innocent. Likewise, speculation about his guilt is not justified either based on facts reported by the media.

As for the "the police never found the knife" argument.... uhh HELLOOO there was obviously a knife! Both men had visible knife wounds; just because it was not found in Marcus' possession does not mean he had nothing to do with the stabbing. Sure, that will mean one less piece of evidence against Marcus in court, but the knife did exist; where is ended up is mildly irrelevant if the case can be proven without that piece of evidence.

Jakester
Wed Apr 1 2009 14:02
So I guess he is going to play the race card so the liberal morons in Amherst can get a feelgood moment when they sprng another violent criminal.
Your name
Tue Feb 17 2009 17:46
Can't wait to see the protests the radicals will launch in order to get another assailant out of jail for stabbing someone. Lets see if justice can be found in this case. You stab another human being regardless of the reason other than justifiable self defense, you should go to jail.
Ricky
Tue Feb 17 2009 14:11
www.chattotextapp.com facebook, myspace, bebo make money on social networks easy
Your name
Tue Feb 17 2009 11:06
Business (in general) comes to mind as the most socially relevant course of work. Not only do you intertwine your major along side projects that give real value to the world, which give people greater standards of living, cure diseases, bring up third world countries and hundreds of millions of people in China and India in the past decades while at the same time making you lots of money. Sure, sociology, african american/women/ethnic studies can make you feel good, but they dont add worth to our society, and many economists (i.e. Thomas Sowell) feel that a lot of efforts on the part of civil rights movements and other "socially relevant" events have caused more harm than good overall.
Your name
Tue Feb 17 2009 02:21
while your gpa comment is legitimate, your stab (pun intended) at sociology as a major was unnecessary... in what other subject area can you intertwine your major, and specifically socially revealing scholarly literature, with community service projects, public awareness campaigns, political activism, and so on? I’m sorry that such a scary incident occurred at Amherst and hope it is resolved to prevent any UMass/Amherst College tensions in the future. PS Lord Jeffs are a lame mascot.
Your name
Mon Feb 16 2009 23:24
Just to point out, to the people here who are throwing around numbers, you all know 3.0 is a B average. Nothing special, most good internships these days are only even applicable for people with 3.5, or in many cases a 3.7 or above gpa. 3.0 is quite low, especially in something like sociology.
Your name
Mon Feb 16 2009 09:17
Oh your a smart one.......it happened at Amherst College, not Umass, I won't even bother with the rest of your ignorance on this.
.
Sun Feb 15 2009 23:39
How about the so called victim was black too, and the person who started the whole conflict. What blows my mind is the only person in trouble is Marcus, but yet, the call to the police was for a double stabbing, apparently the other person had a knife too. Maybe UMass should step up their security, the fight should have been stopped before it even started and surely shouldn't have gone as far as it did.
Your name
Sat Feb 14 2009 22:54
I hear you Marcus' brother, my prayers go out to you and your family. I know your mother loves you both dearly and I know what a loving family Marcus comes from, its just sad that one mistake, one act of self defense can change the whole world's perspective on a honestly good man. I feel as though everyone make mistakes, and it was so wrong what happened but I pray that the other man who was involved in the fight is okay and his family as well and I am so HAPPY to hear that he was not hurt badly....and I pray Marcus can get out of this because he truly deserves a 2nd chance. Knowing him personally, it's tough to hear something like this. I would have never thought this is a million years...... but I feel it had a lot to do with self defense. I hear this kid was a very big dude and came after marcus unexpectedly from more than one source. I want all this to just end.
Your name
Sat Feb 14 2009 22:37
your right there are stab wounds and there is also one is Marcus' hand.... it's not okay to stab someone but people will defend themself when they have to. lol..... Im still trying to understand why people are continuously talking about "the ghetto"..... what about all these white people (and im mixed, best of both worlds) from these rich families, nice areas, who go TO COLLEGE getting their BACHELORS, who are doing drugs, popping pills and drink EVERY SINGLE frigen night at COLLEGE. I've witnessed it with my own eyes..... so stop trying to play goodie 2 shoes cuz mostly all the college students writing on this wall are hypocrits, trying to down other peoples life and the "ghetto". You may have "brains" but you sure don't have heart or common sense... what is someone going to come at me with my english? Get at me cuz i actually got a 3.0 gpa just like man in the pic above.
Your name
Sat Feb 14 2009 22:18
all because an offense involves a black person doesn't mean its "racism" i mean black people do commit crimes along with white people. i mean if the evidence and the circumstances point to someone black or not then they will be brought up on charges. stop trying to relate everything to race.
Your name
Sat Feb 14 2009 20:22
I know this is out of place in the discussion, but I need to go back to the 25 posts all complaining about the lack of a knife. Is it really that important? I mean there is a guy in the hospital with seven stab wounds... they came from somewhere... it isn't like the knife just didn't exist.
rob C
Sat Feb 14 2009 02:38
Whether it was self defense or not (and in this case it seems to be an asymmetric appropriation of violence) the assailant must face trail for his actions.
student
Sat Feb 14 2009 02:00
"I hope 'Justice for Jason' will come and support this black student. He was probably unfairly accused because of his skin color. Cops probably beat him up too..."

"Another blatant baseless accusation by the white people that stench of racism. Totally unacceptable in this age of Obama. Don't worry Marcus Smith, Obama is watching over you. "

By the way, the victim was black, too. This reflexive defense of Smith BECAUSE he is a minority is racism as well, you know.

Your name
Fri Feb 13 2009 20:39
nice to delete my comment collegian... I make the statement that the same people not willing to wait for the facts in the Justice for Jason group are the same ones saying wait till the facts come out in court in this case. Hypocrites, and go ahaed pro Justice for Jason Collegian, not post this opinion....
Your name
Fri Feb 13 2009 18:49
"I think that any student who involves themselves in acts of violence should get their asses thrown in jail and barred from ever attending an institution of higher education."

Yeah, that's a great way to fix problems...keep people uneducated. How wonderful our world would be if we force people to remain in their social classes.

Ending sarcasm now. It's obviously a horrible crime, if he is found guilty. But keeping people like this out of the education system is most certainly not the answer, and to think that it would actually help is very unfortunate and sad.

My brother
Fri Feb 13 2009 17:16
First of all..Marcus is my brother and with all these hateful comments that I have seen it is only giving the media more to say. I have not spoken to my brother since this incident unfortuanately or was I there, but I believe if you were not there you should not judge by what you hear on the media or by what others say. My brother is not an animal, and yes he is human, I do not know what happened but you guys are making him out to be a killer and I'm sure that is not the case. I do hope that the other student involved is okay as well as my brother but until the truth comes out I feel that people should be careful in what they say because both parties involved have loving families like myself who are being exposed to all of this.
Your name
Thu Feb 12 2009 21:35
I cannot believe people continue to be in uproar over issues like this. Whether Smith did it or not will come out in the court system. What I have to take issue is the fact that every time a minority student is involved in some sort of violent incident that results in legal implications, all the liberal students are up in arms trying to defend them. Amherst is the most accepting and liberal community I have ever seen. Yet it is not right to play off some charge of judicial racism when people bring their thug background to a quaint New England community. I think that any student who involves themselves in acts of violence should get their asses thrown in jail and barred from ever attending an institution of higher education. If people cannot conduct themselves as gentlemen and ladies than they have no right being entitled to advanced opportunities for scholarship. It is people like this that the bachelor degree is no longer valued in high esteem. The world today is growing increasingly violent yet people at UMASS have the audacity to speak ill of the military and the war, yet they conduct themselves in a manner such as this. Many of the young people at UMASS really need to rethink their perceptions and grow up.






log out